In a need to refresh myself after all the Love Never Dies BS, I attended last night's performance of Phantom of the Opera on Broadway. I haven't seen the show in about 2 years. I think this made my 17th or 18th performance.
For those of you who don't know, Phantom is why I do what I do. After hearing the title theme when I was 12, I was hooked and said "I want to do that!" Walking into the Majestic Theatre on 44th is almost like walking into a church for me. The Majestic is home, and, God willing, I will one day have my own dressing room there.
Looking through the program, they have made changes in the time period to suit Love Never Dies. Act I has always taken place in 1881, and Act II six months later. It now lists the time period of Act I as "Paris, Late 19th Century." Act II is still 6 months later, and prologue still takes place in 1911...which is the only point in the evening where I tried to "logic" Love Never Dies with the original...assuming Raoul is between 20 and 25 in POTO, that puts him between 30 and 35 in LND...which would make him between 34 and 39 in 1911. Now, I realize Raoul's hard drinking ways in LND might age him prematurely, but, to go from relatively healthy and virile 35 in LND to decrepit 4 years later just doesn't compute. I've always thought Raoul was closer to 70 in the prologue than 40 (that number doesn't work with the show being in 1881, either, but...until the whole LND fiasco, I never thought much about the logistics). Honestly, this was the last thought I had of Love Never Dies for the rest of the evening.
Other curious program happenings...the main cast list in the program now lists FOUR Raouls! Seriously. They each do two shows a week. There are also now two Mme Girys who do four shows a week, and a second M. Andre who does 2 shows a week. I was baffled by this, of course as Christine has always been the only role to have an alternate. The second M Andre at least made some sense since George Lee Andrews has been with the show since day one (over 20 years in the same show, people!) and may have just decided he wanted to take a break, but...the four Raouls? What? My first thought, of course, was a rather sarcastic "After all, Raoul is SUCH a demanding role. Who could possibly manage 8 shows a week?" Well, it turns out, it has something to do with contract overlap because of the US tour closing. Really would like to know how that all actually works, though.
After over 20 years of being familiar with Phantom of the Opera, after seeing it nearly 20 times, and after several auditions for it, it still captivates me. I still get that feeling of excitement in my stomach, the anticipation as the auctioneer begins "Lot 666, then, a chandelier in pieces...." I felt myself lean forward in my seat, my body tensing, my lips moving through the words. My neck and shoulder muscles today are actually tight from the tension in my body as I watched the show last night. No other show has ever affected me this way. In fact, I have a bad back and sitting in theatre seats is very uncomfortable for me. I tend to shift a lot and worry I'm disturbing people around me. Not so with Phantom. I don't think I moved except to lean forward from the moment the lights dimmed for Act I until intermission, and then from the Entr'acte to the curtain call.
I think this is the first time I've seen the show since the Majestic installed a new digital sound system. It was actually a noticeably better sound quality. I heard a few nuances in the orchestration I have only heard on cast recordings to this point. It is also the first time I have VERY clearly heard the electric rock guitar riffs at the end of the title theme. I have never heard that outside of the Steve Harley/Sarah Brightman music video. I'm not sure if they've always been there and just not amped enough, or if they've been added back in (as a possible tie in with LND because of the rocked out Beauty Underneath?).
The cast last night...before getting into this, I have to say, my first Phantom cast was the sit down production in Los Angeles in the early 90's. To this day, no one can compare to Leigh Munro (Carlotta), Barbara Lang (Mme. Giry), Calvin Remsberg (M. Firmin), Norman Large (M. Andre), or Davis Gaines (Phantom) for me. To me, they are the definitive of who and what those characters should be, and every subsequent performer I see is held to those standards.
Patricia Phillips was Carlotta. I think I've seen here 2 or 3 times now. She's OK. She doesn't always sing the top notes in Prima Donna, but she was vocally "on" last night.
Evan Harrington leaves me kind of cold as Piangi. I've seen several excellent Piangis. When they don't hold out the top G in Hannibal (Your army HAAAAaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaas), I feel let down. Evan just kind of popped up to it and off it. He did make a nice show of getting on the elephant. He seemed very prop-like to me, though.
The Managers have been with the NY production since day 1. I enjoy them.
As Mme. Giry, I felt Mary Illes was too...soft, I guess is the best word. I like a Mme. Giry who is somewhat biting. She seemed more motherly overall, and not the mysterious keeper of the Phantom's secrets I expect her to be. She also seemed a little young for the role.
Heather McFadden has been playing Meg Giry forever, it seems - she is now also the assistant dance captain. I'm pretty sure she was 16 when she started - I remember reading in her bio a few years ago that she was attending a performing arts high school at the time. It was kind of strange to read her bio last night and see that she is now married and has two children! She is a lovely dancer. Her singing has improved over the years.
Christine. *sigh* As you can imagine, I am harshest on Christines. Out of all the productions and casts I've seen, I have like ONE Christine. This was my second or third time seeing Jennifer Hope-Wills in the role. The first time was very early on in her Broadway run (funny story about the first time I saw her - she was having issues with her dress in the Graveyard Scene. I saw her kind of kick the hem out of her way a couple times and stumble once or twice. As Raoul was trying to take her away, she finally tripped and fell. Tim Martin Gleason had his back to her and didn't notice at first and dragged her a few steps before realizing she had fallen and helping her up. The timing on the scene got a bit awkward). At the time, she was constantly just *slightly* under pitch. She has improved, and was on pitch all night. Unfortunately, I can't stand her voice - I was literally cringing in my seat several times through out the evening. She has a very thin quality, odd phrasing, a pretty inconsistent (bad) British accent, and seems to be singing right in her nose a lot of the time. The colour of her voice is a little too young for my taste, and more a sound I associate with Meg. She hits the cadenza in Think of Me like a sledge hammer. The first part of it sounds much too heavy, so that the high C, which she hits very differently, sounds out of place. I will say, while I was unimpressed with most of her performance, she was one of the stronger Christines I've seen in the final lair scene. Honestly, however, her voice bothers me so much that I will make a point of seeing the alternate Christine as long as she remains the main Christine.
Jeremy Stolle was last nights Raoul. Handsome man, and one of the taller Raouls I've seen - I do like Raoul to be tall! He started out well enough, more a baritone than I'm used to...unfortunately, he got a rather "Dudley Do Right" quality to his voice in higher sections ("How young and innocent we were") I almost laughed. He seems to sing from the neck up. He also had some odd ways of phrasing - but when he spoke, not so much when he sang. He was very lovely with Christine during Twisted Every Way, which is one of my deciding factors for whether or not I like an actor in the role. Raoul's delivery of the final line in that scene will make or break the character for me. Jeremy's delivery kind left me feeling...meh...it wasn't weak, but, it wasn't terribly strong, either. I didn't feel too much tension from him in the Final Lair. He stood pretty relaxed there with the noose around his neck. I never got the impression that HE felt he was in danger. I guess, this also comes from my experiences with Michael Piontek's Raoul in LA. He had devised a manner of standing on tip-toe so that he REALLY looked like he was in danger of strangulation.
I think this is the first time I've seen a Broadway Phantom who wasn't Howard McGillian. John Cudia is also the first Phantom who isn't Davis Gaines whose voice I have REALLY liked. He has a very smooth, beautiful, and powerful voice. I did feel he was just "going through the motions" for some of it, and that he lacked a lot of nuance and dynamic in his voice - a lot of it seemed just like singing at top volume. I felt his laughter when he's making Carlotta croak like a toad and his "GO!" when releasing the chandelier were very tossed off. He is probably one of the more physically violent Phantoms I have seen during the final lair scene. He really grabbed Christine and kind of contorted her to the ground - I had a brief moment of "Ohhh...I don't think my back would handle that l if I were his Christine!"
Even though I felt this cast was a bit weak, the show completely held together for me. I know every note, every movement (seriously, except for the Hannibal ballet and Masquerade, I could go on for either Christine or Carlotta with one or two put-in rehearsals at this point. I don't know that that's pathetic or a bragging point, but, it's true), and yet I am completely enthralled each time I see it. I wouldn't think twice about seeing it again.
Leaving the theatre, I had a feeling of complete contentment. Satisfied with the ending - yes, it IS an ending, NOT a cliffhanger that begs for a sequel. My iPod is a constant fixture with me. As long as I am not doing something that requires I be able to hear what's going on, the earphones are firmly in place and music is playing. After walking out of the theatre, I couldn't bring myself to listen to other music. I needed to just let everything settle. When I got on the subway, I knew what I had to listen to was the Phantasia Suite. It was perfect. It's exactly the right length to get me from 44th to my front door, and the perfect way to decompress.
Great review! I saw your link on the LSD Facebook page and had to stop by to read it. As a fellow long-time fan (since the age of three), it was a thoroughly enjoyable read and made some great points. It also makes me want to see Phantom on Broadway or in London more than ever. Thus far, I've seen it only on tour. The most recent time was the first time I had noticed the Steve Harley-esque electric guitar riffs at the end of the title song. I do believe that was deliberate to tie in more with the rock themes of LND.
ReplyDeleteWhen I saw the show on tour in May, the Phantom was played by an understudy, so I'm not sure if this was a new addition or if it was just his personal touch, but when Christine is kneeling before him during "Down Once More/Track Down This Murderer," did the Phantom shout at her? He had never done this in my previous experience, nor in cast recordings, but this time he very clearly yelled, "GET UP!" It was so loud, in fact, that the theater reverberated with the sound. Do you happen to remember if this happened in New York as well? I'm just curious at this point.
Nice to see another well-written review demonstrating that not all fans are fond of LND or "sad, pathetic people," as ALW would have it!
Thanks so much for coming by to read and taking the time to comment. :)
ReplyDeleteWow. No, I have never heard a Phantom tell Christine to "Get up" during the final lair. It sounds like one of those "in the moment" things for that actor.